Vents control the fire; the lid turns a grill into an oven
The 5 highest scores among the 8 charcoal grills we cover that have a checked Amazon.com listing. Scores are out of ten and only compare models inside this category.
| # | Model | Our score | Price | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Napoleon PRO22K-LEG-3Best for: A charcoal cook who smokes with a probe, roasts on a spit, and wants to move the grid rather than the coals | 8.7/10 | ≈ $389 | Check price on Amazon: Napoleon PRO22K-LEG-3 |
| 2 | Megamaster 810-23002Best for: The most cooking area per dollar on this shelf, if you can live without the lid hook | 8.1/10 | ≈ $97 | Check price on Amazon: Megamaster 810-23002 |
| 3 | Weber 14516001 Master-Touch Deep Ocean BlueBest for: Someone who wants the Master-Touch and does not want a black grill | 8.1/10 | ≈ $309 | Check price on Amazon: Weber 14516001 Master-Touch Deep Ocean Blue |
| 4 | Weber 1321001 Jumbo Joe PremiumBest for: The best capacity per dollar on this shelf, for anyone who cooks over one load of charcoal | 8.1/10 | ≈ $98 | Check price on Amazon: Weber 1321001 Jumbo Joe Premium |
| 5 | Weber 14501001 Master-TouchBest for: A charcoal cook who wants fine airflow control and room to expand with inserts | 8.1/10 | ≈ $289 | Check price on Amazon: Weber 14501001 Master-Touch |
Prices are indicative and were read on Amazon.com; the button shows the current one. If we earn a commission, it does not change the order.
A charcoal grill is controlled by air, not by a dial, and the parts that do that are the ones worth paying for. Vents at the bottom and in the lid set how fast the fuel burns; a lid that seals lets you cut the air and cook indirectly, which is the difference between grilling sausages and roasting a chicken outdoors. Cooking diameter should be read against how you cook rather than how many you feed, because indirect cooking needs half the grate empty. Ash management decides whether the thing gets cleaned. We compare vent design and lid sealing, cooking diameter, grate material, ash collection and indirect capability.
18 in kettle charcoal grill, stated for 1–4 people, with wheels, handles and a built-in ash collector, assembled by one person in 15 minutes
An 18-inch kettle for fifty-three dollars, assembled in a stated fifteen minutes by one person.
Best for: A first kettle, a gift, or a small household that grills for two
22 in charcoal kettle with 354 sq in of cooking space, a porcelain-enamelled lid and bowl, adjustable air dampers, a removable ash catcher and a storage rack
A 22-inch porcelain-enamelled kettle with 354 published square inches, at twenty-seven cents a square inch.
Best for: The most cooking area per dollar on this shelf, if you can live without the lid hook
≈ $97
22 in charcoal kettle in Deep Ocean Blue with a Tuck-Away lid holder, hinged GBS-compatible grate, built-in lid thermometer, tool hooks, and taller legs with char-basket fuel holders stated in the description
The Master-Touch in Deep Ocean Blue, whose listing also names taller legs and char-basket fuel holders.
Best for: Someone who wants the Master-Touch and does not want a black grill
≈ $309
22 in compact charcoal grill with 363 sq in of cooking surface, a porcelain-enamelled lid and bowl, plated steel grate, aluminum dampers and ash catcher, an angled lid hook and a heat-shielded lid handle
Three hundred and sixty-three square inches for ninety-eight dollars, with an angled lid hook and a heat-shielded handle.
Best for: The best capacity per dollar on this shelf, for anyone who cooks over one load of charcoal
≈ $98
22 in charcoal kettle with a Tuck-Away lid holder, hinged Gourmet BBQ System grate, warming rack, built-in lid thermometer, One-Touch cleaning with a removable high-capacity ash catcher, 3 air vents with 3 swivelling damper blades and two 8 in rubber-molded wheels
The only kettle here to publish its vent count, and the only one whose grate takes wok and griddle inserts.
Best for: A charcoal cook who wants fine airflow control and room to expand with inserts
≈ $289
22 in charcoal kettle with a porcelain-enamelled lid and bowl, One-Touch cleaning system with an aluminized steel ash catcher, aluminum damper, angled lid hook, tool hooks and a 10 year limited warranty
The only kettle here with a warranty in its bullets — ten years limited — plus the One-Touch cleaning system.
Best for: The sensible middle of this shelf, with its warranty in plain view
≈ $149
22 in charcoal kettle with a built-in lid thermometer, hinged cooking grate, One-Touch cleaning system with a removable high-capacity aluminized ash catcher, porcelain-enamelled lid and bowl, glass-reinforced nylon handles and an angled lid hook
The kettle that adds a lid thermometer and a hinged grate, which is what lets you roast and refuel.
Best for: Anyone who wants to roast and smoke as well as sear — the first kettle here that can
≈ $219
22 in charcoal kettle with hinged cast iron grids adjustable to three heights, a Vortex heat management system, a Smoke Stack Chimney, a stainless steel extension ring with rotisserie spit ports and temperature probe doors, an offset hinged lid and chrome-plated cooking grids
The only kettle here with grids at three heights, probe doors and rotisserie ports, at 28 kg (61.7 lb).
Best for: A charcoal cook who smokes with a probe, roasts on a spit, and wants to move the grid rather than the coals
≈ $389
The diameter commands the available grill surface. Crowded, nothing browns properly and everything ends up steaming.
A small model heats with less charcoal, stores away and moves about. For two or three people, a large grill costs fuel for nothing.
A firebox with no ash pan means tipping the whole thing over, which puts people off cleaning and clogs the base. A stated removable ash pan decides the life of the bowl.
Twenty-five to thirty-five minutes after lighting, when the embers are covered in gray ash. Cooking over flames burns the outside and leaves the inside raw.
For plain grilling, no. To cook a whole chicken or a large joint, it is indispensable: the lid makes the oven.
A chimney starter and some paper: it is faster, safer and with no petroleum taste. It is the best accessory in the range.
To set the temperature: more air, hotter. The lower vent feeds the fire, the upper one draws the heat.
Lump charcoal goes higher and faster, briquettes hold a stable temperature longer. Short-lived embers against long cooking.
Keep a zone free of embers to move the meat to. The lid, by cutting off the air, also smothers the flames.
At every use, once completely cold. Ash blocks the lower air intake and rusts the kettle through the moisture it holds.
Brush the grill hot just after cooking: the residue comes away on its own. Cold and hardened, it takes ten times the effort.
Wait for the gray ash, set the heat with the vents, keep an ember-free zone and brush the grill while it is still hot. A chimney starter replaces any liquid firelighter to advantage, and a lid turns the grill into an oven.
We show a column only when four utensils in five publish its value. The rest would stay empty and settle nothing.
| Model | Price | Diameter | Lid parking | Overall dimensions | Thermometer |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Megamaster 810-23002 | $97 | 22 in | None stated — no hook and no holder | 25.2 × 22.8 × 36.6 in (640 × 580 × 930 mm) | None |
| Weber 1321001 Jumbo Joe Premium | $98 | 22 in | An angled lid hook — slide the lid on rather than setting it on the ground | 24 × 9.80 × 38.2 in (610 × 249 × 970 mm) | None |
| Weber 741001 Original Kettle | $149 | 22 in | An angled lid hook | 25 × 25 × 39.5 in (635 × 635 × 1003 mm), about 39.5 in tall | None — the $219 Premium adds it |
| Weber 14401001 Original Kettle Premium | $219 | 22 in | An angled lid hook | — | Built-in lid thermometer, showing the internal temperature |
| Weber 14501001 Master-Touch | $289 | 22 in | Tuck-Away lid holder — the lid slides into a holder on the side | 42 × 24 × 29.5 in (1067 × 610 × 749 mm) — about 42 in tall | Built-in lid thermometer |
| Weber 14516001 Master-Touch Deep Ocean Blue | $309 | 22 in | Tuck-Away lid holder on the side | 24 × 29.5 × 42 in (610 × 749 × 1067 mm) — about 42 in tall | Built-in lid thermometer |
| Napoleon PRO22K-LEG-3 | $389 | 22 in | — | 28.5 × 23 × 42 in (724 × 584 × 1067 mm) — about 42 in tall | — |
| GRILIFE YH22017D | — | 18 in — the only kettle here that is not 22 in | None stated — no hook and no holder | 21.7 × 18 × 30 in (550 × 457 × 762 mm) | None |
$289 – $389
3 models
Weber 14501001 Master-Touch, Weber 14516001 Master-Touch Deep Ocean Blue, Napoleon PRO22K-LEG-3
Specifications: manufacturer sheets for cookware and kitchen knives and the matching Amazon product pages. Prices and availability: Keepa. Every figure in this table names its source.
Most recent revision in this category: October 31, 2026.
Prices quoted in these summaries are dated readings. The live price is shown next to each product.
