Skip to content

Farberware Cookstart 12.25 in review

The cheapest large nonstick pan here at about $15, with a 350°F oven limit and a coating claim you cannot check.

Photo : Reinis Brūzītis, Unsplash

What you are getting

A 12.25-inch aluminum pan with DiamondMax nonstick, a dual-riveted handle and a 350°F oven rating, at about $15.

Why cheap can be the right answer

Every coated pan wears out. A $15 pan that lasts two years costs less per year than many premium pans, which makes this a legitimate choice rather than a compromise. Our guide to replacing a coated pan goes through that reasoning.

Where it sits

It is the largest and cheapest pan on this shelf, and it has the lowest oven limit. The Tramontina Professional is the step up, at more than double the price.

Prices quoted in this text are dated readings and can differ from the live price in the buy box.

What we rate, and what we do not

Strengths

  • About $15 for a 12.25-inch pan
  • Dishwasher safe
  • A limited lifetime warranty at this price

Compromises

  • "3X better than ceramic" is not explained in the listing
  • The lowest oven limit here at 350°F
  • Induction is not mentioned

Specifications

Diameter12.25 in (31 cm)
CoatingDiamondMax nonstick
BodyHeavy-duty aluminum
HandleDual riveted
Oven350°F
DishwasherYes
InductionNot stated
WarrantyLimited lifetime
Amazon referenceB0BJ7LM9LR

The questions that come in

Is DiamondMax actually diamond?

The listing gives no composition. It says only that the coating performs 3X better than ceramic nonstick, without saying how that was measured, so treat it as a brand name.

Can it go in the oven?

Yes, to 350°F. That is fine for keeping food warm or finishing a frittata, not for a hot sear-then-roast.

Our score

7.8/ 10

Very cheap and perfectly sensible as a replaceable pan. Nonstick wears out anyway.

This one against the other cookware and knives

Close prices, same category: comparable cookware and knives. We keep only the specifications all of them publish, because a column with gaps compares nothing.

Model Price CoatingOven
Farberware Cookstart 12.25 in $15 DiamondMax nonstick350°F
Tramontina Professional 12 in $38 Nonstick; type not named in the listing400°F (204°C)
T-fal Experience 12-inch nonstick frying pan, induction $45 Platinum nonstick, “up to 10X” more resistant than T-fal basic; Prometal Pro, metal-utensil safeUp to 400°F
T-Fal Ultimate 12 in with Lid $55 Titanium nonstick, stated 3x longer lasting than basic T-fal coatingPan to 400°F, lid to 350°F, broiler stated in the title

What sets the models apart, in cookware and knives

  • If price decides: this model, at $15.
  • Highest Oven in the table: T-Fal Ultimate 12 in with Lid (Pan to 400°F, lid to 350°F, broiler stated in the title).

What use this one answers, among cookware and knives

A spare pan, a rental or a first kitchen.

Where this model is cited, among our cookware and knives guides

Sources

Specifications: the manufacturer sheet for cookware and kitchen knives and the matching Amazon product page. Prices and availability: Keepa. Every figure on this page names its source.

What we judge these cookware and knives on

Prices quoted in these summaries are dated readings. The live price is shown next to each product.